The removal of subsidies increased revenue inflow into the Federation Account from an average of N650 billion per month to over N1 trillion over the last four months, according to Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of Economy, Wale Edun.
Making this disclosure at a four-day retreat held in Asaba, Delta state capital, Edun said that the economic reforms that the President Bola Tinubu-led administration had undertaken since its inception clearly outlined the right steps towards the transformation of the country’s economy.
Mr Edun’s statement was read by the ministry’s Permanent Secretary, Mr. Okokon Udo.
“The economic reforms which this administration has undertaken since its inception in May, 2023 clearly outlined right steps to transformation of the country’s economy.In less than six months of the administration, we have witnessed the introduction of important reforms, such as petroleum subsidy removal, fiscal and monetary policies reforms aimed at removing multiple taxation among others,” he said.
“The Federation Account in particular is witnessing improved revenue inflow since the removal of subsidy from an average of N650 billion monthly to over N1 trillion in the last four months.The government had for long realised that petroleum subsidy is not sustainable given it erodes revenues that should have been available to fund viable expenditures that are critical to wellbeing of the populace,” he added.
He claimed that two of Tinubu’s administration’s main goals are to reach the 22 percent tax revenue to GDP target and the 18 percent tax to GDP target by 2026.
Naija News recalls that President Tinubu had on assumption of office immediately removed fuel subsidy and floated the country’s currency.
South Africa will Tuesday host a virtual summit of the BRICS group of nations, including Russian President Vladimir Putin, to discuss the Israel-Hamas war, Pretoria and Moscow said Monday.
The BRICS — Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa — are a group of major emerging economies seeking to reshape the US and Western-led global order.
Tuesday’s “Extraordinary Joint Meeting on the Middle East Situation in Gaza” will be hosted by South African President Cyril Ramaphosa in the hope of drawing up a common response to the more than six-week conflict.
Leaders from Saudi Arabia, Argentina, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran and the United Arab Emirates — who are all due to join the BRICS group in January 2024 — will attend the meeting.
UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres will also participate, the South African presidency said in a statement.
It added that all five BRICS heads of state will join the virtual summit, after which a joint statement with particular reference to Gaza is expected.
Fighting is raging in Gaza after a shock Hamas attack on Israel on October 7 killed about 1,200 people, mostly civilians, with around 240 people taken hostage, according to Israeli officials.
In Gaza, around 13,300 people, more than 5,500 of them children, have been killed in the retaliatory air and ground offensive, officials in the Hamas-run territory have said.
South Africa has long been a vocal supporter of the Palestinian cause, with the ruling African National Congress (ANC) party often linking it to its own struggle against apartheid.
The ANC said last Thursday that it would support a parliamentary motion to suspend diplomatic relations with Israel until it agrees to a ceasefire in Gaza, decrying the “genocidal actions of the Israeli regime”.
On Friday, South Africa joined four other nations in calling for an International Criminal Court investigation into the Israel-Hamas war.
China has historically been sympathetic to the Palestinians and supportive of a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Beijing has been calling for an immediate ceasefire since the start of the war last month.
Russian President Vladimir Putin has accused the West of stoking tensions in the Middle East, and criticised Israel for its conduct in the conflict.
Putin skipped the last BRICS annual summit in Johannesburg as he is the target of an International Criminal Court arrest warrant — a provision that South Africa as an ICC member would be expected to implement if he were to set foot in the country
The Enugu State Governor Peter Mbah has assured that his administration would continue to train at least 40,000 youths across the state on relevant digital and entrepreneurial skills that would enable them to compete in the global digital and entrepreneurial markets.
The governor gave this assurance while delivering a keynote address at the Enugu Tech and Entrepreneurship with the theme, “Innovation Unleashed: Transforming Enugu’s Future”.
“We want them to embrace the emerging future of robotics, artificial intelligence, augmented reality, virtual reality, and disruptive innovation through skills in information and technology,” he said on Sunday.
“Our administration would train at least 40,000 youths across the state on relevant digital and entrepreneurial skills that would enable them to compete in the global digital and entrepreneurial markets.”
According to him, his administration had already commenced the training of youths on digital innovation, programming, digital marketing, financial technology, and entrepreneurship, among other requisite technological, financial, and business skills.
Mbah is optimistic that with the right training and skills, which his government is determined to facilitate by partnering with different tech industries and stakeholders, the youths could create their own greener pastures in Nigeria without having to travel overseas.
“With the right training and skills which my government would facilitate by partnering with different reputable tech industries, our youths can create their own greener pasture in Nigeria without having to travel abroad. And with their own innovation here, they can create greener pastures on the Enugu soil,” the governor said.
Yesterday, I had the pleasure of being the keynote speaker at the second edition of the Enugu Tech and Entrepreneurship (TxE) Summit. I was privileged to perform the same role at the inaugural edition in 2022.
— Peter Ndubuisi Mbah (@PNMbah) November 19, 2023
Speaking on the theme: "Innovation Unleashed: Transforming Enugu’s… pic.twitter.com/7nQCndWoXo
Press Statement on Lagos State Public Procurement Agency’s Reaction to the Open Letter by Mr. Funso Doherty
AdminOur attention has been drawn to recent concerns regarding certain information posted on the Lagos State Public Procurement Agency's website. Acknowledging the misunderstandings arising from a lack of clarity, we recognize the unintended misinterpretations of this information.
The Agency is committed to ensuring transparency, accuracy, and accountability in all government transactions, as mandated by the Lagos State Public Procurement Law. We regret that specific details, particularly concerning the descriptions of government dealings, may have inadvertently led to confusion, impacting both governmental entities and corporate partners providing services to the State. This arose largely from the lack of detailed descriptions in the project information, which has inadvertently led to contusion in the public space.
We empathize with public concerns and extend our sincere apologies for any distress caused. It's never our intent to cast doubt or cause misunderstandings that might tarnish the reputation of respected individuals and organizations involved in these transactions.
To address these concerns thoroughly, the Agency has taken immediate steps. Line-by-line explanations of the contracts in question are attached herewith, aiming to provide absolute clarity and dispel any lingering misconceptions.
The Agency will continue to improve its internal processes and communication methods as our commitment as a government is to offer clearer and more accessible information to the public. It is pivotal to stress that the Agency's autonomy exists to ensure fairness and transparency, not to cause confusion or discredit any involved parties. We therefore assure the public of our unwavering dedication to upholding the highest standards of integrity in all our operations. Looking ahead, we pledge our continued commitment to consistently and accurately report all government transactions in the State.
Our unwavering commitment remains to elevate the standard of living and enhancing the quality of life for the people of Lagos. Rest assured, this commitment will always take precedence.
Mr Fatal idowu Onafowote
The Director-General
Lagos State Public Procurement Agency
LAGOS STATE PUBLIC PROCUREMENT AGENCY’S REACTION TO THE OPEN LETTER BY MR FUNSO DOHERTY
STATING THE FACTS AND FIGURES
|
SN |
MDA |
DESCRIPTION OF AWARD |
NAIRA AMOUNT |
DATE |
VENDOR |
COMMENTS |
RESPONSE FROM LAGOS STATE GOVERNMENT |
|
1. |
Lagos Metropolitan Area Transport Authority (LAMATA) |
Construction, Supply & Installation of Operation and Maintenance (0&M) Infrastructure of LRMT Blue Line Phase 1 from Marina to Mile 2 |
40,188.644,336 |
Apr-23 |
China Civil Engineering Construction Company (CCECC) Nigeria Limited |
The Blue Line was planned to be operated and maintained by a qualiRied and competent operator on a PPP basis. This arrangement is not in place, but train operations have started. Who is performing that function presently and who will manage, operate and maintain this Operations and Maintenance (0&M) Infrastructure that is now being procured by LASG from the main contractor (CCECC) at a cost of N40bn? Is it LAMATA? If so, does it have the capacity? How are safety, efRiciency, accountability and Rinancial results being assured, monitored and reported? |
The Blue Line Rail Project's design and construction were entrusted to Messr CCECC Nigeria Limited. Subsequently, upon Rinalizing the Rixed infrastructure, a two-year partial operation contract was executed with the contractor for the following purposes: ▪ bolster the technical and operational expertise of LAMATA’s teams, fostering their capacity. ▪ meticulously gather scientiRic Rinancial and revenue data essential for informed decision-making processes. ▪ equip pertinent practitioners with the necessary information crucial for forthcoming concessioning procedures. ▪ empower the contractor to promptly address any defects identiRied during the operational phase of the project. |
|
2. |
Construction of Lagos Rail Mass Transit (LRMT) blue line Mile 2 to Okokomaiko (section 2) |
218,071,301,485 |
Jul-23 |
China Civil Engineering Construction Company (CCECC) Nigeria Limited |
In 2008, N70bn was approved for the Blue line and it was expected to be completed by 2011. Phase 1 of the project, Marina to Mile 2, which is approximately half of the total proposed length, has just recently commenced limited operations in 2023. The overall cost incurred so far has not been disclosed. With this award of Phase 2 by LASG to the same contractor, at a cost of N218n, what |
Phase 1 faced signiRicant delays due to insufRicient funds. The current administration's strategy successfully realized the Blue Line Rail Project. The Governor remains dedicated to completing section 2 during this term, employing the same approach used for phase 1. Section 2 has already been entrusted to Messr CCECC Nigeria Limited, seamlessly continuing the project with ongoing execution. In a commendable move, the Lagos State Government compensated veriRied property |
|
safeguards are in place to prevent a repeat occurrence? |
owners and tenants, following a globally accepted standard—a practice that will continue as needed. |
||||||
|
3. |
Consultancy Service for the update of the strategic Transport and Mobility Master Plan for Lagos Mega City Area |
5,380,695,140 |
Sep-23 |
Advanced Engineering Consultants (AEC) / ROM Transportation Engineering |
Advanced Engineering Consultants (AEC) and ROM Transportation have been engaged to update the Strategic Transport and Mobility Master Plan (STMP) at a cost of approximately N5.5bn. However, the same company, AEC is also engaged by LASG in implementing multiple aspects of the STMP. They have been awarded contracts for the Bus Corridors (see below), as well as the design of the fourth Mainland Bridge. It is not good practice and is a conRlict of interest to engage a participating contractor with a vested interest in speciRic design or implementation contracts to develop or update the master plan |
The Consultancy Service for updating the Strategic Transport and Mobility Master Plan for the Lagos Mega City Area was awarded to Messrs. ROM Transportation Engineering Ltd in collaboration with Advanced Engineering Consultants (AEC) after a rigorous 15-month competitive procurement process led by LAMATA, AFD, and PPA. The awarded contract, valued at ₦1,167,451,900.54 plus €4,213,243.24, spans 24 months. While ROM Transportation Engineering Ltd serves as the principal consultant, AEC, as the local partner, facilitates engagement with various stakeholders and facilitates knowledge transfer. It's essential to differentiate between the STMMP and EPCS contracts: the former involves upgrading the existing STMP to guide the Lagos State Government on transportation infrastructure development, whereas the latter pertains to implementing recommendations from the current STMP and is Rinanced by AFD. |
|
|
4. |
Consultancy Service for the detailed engineering design and supervision of construction of quality bus corridor package 1 (Ketu/Alapere, Yaba-Lawanson- Cele), Package 2 (lju Ishaga-Abule Egba) and Package 3 (lyana-Iba-Igando) |
7,361,406,710 |
May-23 |
Advanced Engineering Consultants (AEC) / GPO Group SA |
See above. AEC appears to be a recurring feature across a number of very substantial LASG/LAMATA contract awards. It is not apparent from evidence in the public domain that projects AEC has undertaken, outside of LASG projects, justify the prominence accorded it by LASG. Remarkably, recently, in Sept 2023, the current Federal Minister of Works announced a proposed Lagos-Abuja "Super-Highway" intended to operate on a concessioned, PPP basis and |
The Detailed Engineering Design and Construction Supervision procurement for Quality Bus Corridor Package 1, 2 & 3 commenced in December 2019, culminating in the award to AEC/GPO S.A. in September 2021. Subsequently, the contract underwent revision to incorporate an Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) component. After Rinalizing this process, a revised award was ofRicially issued in April 2023, following thorough certiRication by AFD. |
|
Including design and supervision of ITS for 4 Nos of quality bus corridors. |
presented AEC as the entity that would lead the consortium to partner with the FGN |
||||||
|
5. |
Consultancy Services for the engagement of Loan Facilitator and Adviser on LRMT blue line project |
2,101,321,622 |
May-23 |
Iroko Capital |
This award should be scrutinized for Value-for-Money. LASG should not be engaging consultants for this purpose at a high Rixed cost. If deemed necessary, a modest engagement retainer (a fraction of this amount) combined with a more substantive fee that is contingent and payable upon successful fundraising, commercial and Rinancial close should be negotiated through a competitive selection process. |
The consultant played a key role in securing funding for the Blue and Red Lines through local Nigerian banks, a shift from the initial plan of acquiring a USD loan from the international community. This strategic move mitigated the State's exposure to exchange rate risks. Negotiating the fee down from 5% to 2.5% was another achievement. The operational Blue Line stands as a testament to the successful completion of the project within the stipulated timeframe, showcasing its numerous associated beneRits. The decision averted the risks associated with Rluctuating exchange rates, ensuring stability and fostering favorable outcomes from the investment. |
|
|
6. |
Consultancy Services for the engagement of Loan transaction arranger and Financial Adviser to LASG/LAMATA on the Red line project |
3,141,666,667 |
May-23 |
Iroko Capital |
Ditto |
The consultant played a key role in securing funding for the Blue and Red Lines through local Nigerian banks, a shift from the initial plan of acquiring a USD loan from the international community. This strategic move mitigated the State's exposure to exchange rate risks. Negotiating the fee down from 5% to 2.5% was another achievement. The operational Blue Line stands as a testament to the successful completion of the project within the stipulated timeframe, showcasing its numerous associated beneRits. The decision averted the risks associated with Rluctuating exchange rates, ensuring stability and fostering favorable outcomes from the investment. |
|
|
7. |
Ministry of Works and Infrastructure |
Rehabilitation / Reconstruction/ upgrade of Eti-Osa / Lekki / Epe |
69,936,201,915 |
Aug-23 |
Craneburg Construction |
This single award for the repair and upgrade of a section of an already existing road amounts to approximately half of the entire 2023 |
The contractor who has previously been prequaliRied was already engaged in on-site operations, speciRically focusing on the road infrastructure starting from the T junction in |
|
Expressway (Phase 2b) from Greensprings to Abraham Adesanya in Eti-Osa and Ibeju- Lekki LGA |
budget for the Ministry of Works and Infrastructure. A comprehensive and preferably independent, value-for-money assessment should be done for this contract. Also see additional comment below. |
the Epe axis. Notably, the road structure is primarily concrete-based, and the contractor has initiated the project using its internal Rinancial resources for up to 50% of cost. Subsequent disbursement of funds by the LASG is planned to span across over 24months utilizing an ISPO. Moreover, the BOQ pertinent to this project has undergone thorough assessment and scrutiny by the OfRice of Infrastructure to ensure accuracy and appropriateness in line with the project's scope and speciRications. |
|||||
|
8. |
Construction of identiRied strategic roads across the state in Alimosho LGA (2 Roads), Ikeja LGA (3 Roads), Ifako ljaiye LGA (6 Roads) and Kosofe LGA (4 Roads) (Lot 3) |
6,047,509,151 |
Sep-23 |
LagField Construction Limited |
This is one of 3 large contract awards to 3 contractors with multiple roads per local Government in each award. Based on our experience in Lagos, apart from quality and value-for- money considerations, commuter experience during construction must be considered and prioritized. Work should be properly phased having regard to LASG's funding capacity. Contractor plans to mitigate hardship and disruption must form part of the contract and must be jointly agreed, monitored and enforced. LASG should also, even as it awards additional road contracts, address the several unRinished and dilapidated roads and road projects on key arteries across the State that are contributing to trafRic gridlock, crime, health conditions and reduced quality of life |
The BOQ underwent comprehensive evaluation conducted by OfRice of Infrastructure, ensuring meticulous scrutiny and validation of the project's quantitative aspects. Simultaneously, the Ministry of Transportation remains actively engaged in project oversight. This involvement facilitates the implementation of necessary trafRic diversions, supported by the deployment of trafRic ofRicers at strategic locations to guarantee uninterrupted trafRic Rlow during project execution. Payment disbursement for projects adheres to a certiRied measured works framework, ensuring that the total allocated sum is not released in a single transaction. Instead, payments are processed incrementally based on certiRied progress, with an initial advance payment set at 40% of the total project cost. Regarding the restoration of deteriorated roads, the Lagos State Government's Public Works Corporation shoulders the responsibility of rectifying such infrastructural deRiciencies. The Corporation is well-equipped and proRiciently positioned to execute this mandate, ensuring |
|
the effective rehabilitation of dilapidated road networks across the state. |
|||||||
|
9. |
Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources |
Procurement and Construction and Design, Build Operate and Maintain PPP Model for the Blueline Rail |
9,714,179,610 |
Sep-23 |
Lamp Turnkey Project / Viathan Engineering Limited |
This relates to an Independent Power Plant proposed to power the Blue Line Rail on a Design, Build, Operate and Maintain PPP Model. This was originally intended to be Rinanced by the concessionaire. From this award, it now appears that the setup cost is being borne by LASG. The award makes reference to a PPP, but it is not evident that a PPP process has been advertised, undertaken or disclosed by the LASG PPP OfRice. It is therefore not clear on what basis this N9.7 bn contract was awarded, whether a concession is involved and what terms are provided for. |
During the initial stages of project conceptualization, the contractor was tasked with executing the project under a Public Private Partnership (PPP) framework entailing the Build, Operate, Maintain, and Transfer model. Following due process, the contractor successfully secured the project bid. However, it became imperative to develop a comprehensive and detailed design to accurately estimate the project cost. Design considerations constitute a substantial segment, accounting for approximately 15% of the overall project expenditure. In the pursuit of facilitating the PPP arrangement, Rinancial backers stipulated the requirement for a Fiscally Backed Irrevocable Standing Payment Order (ISPO) supported by the Federation Account Allocation Committee (FAAC). Regrettably, the Lagos State Government (LASG) was unable to comply with this condition. Given the critical timing and signiRicance of the project, LASG made a strategic decision to independently Rinance the Engineering, Procurement, and Construction (EPC) component of the project. This intervention proved pivotal, expediting the project's progress signiRicantly, particularly in advancing the power plant construction phase to an advanced stage. Notably, while the entirety of the project remains under the PPP framework, this speciRic segment was funded by the State owing to the exigencies of the project timeline and its strategic importance. |
|
10. |
Lagos State Residents Registration Agency |
Provision of Support Services for the Multi-biometric search service (MBSS) platform for the deployment of disaster recovery site and upgrade of Database infrastructure from 10M to 20M to the agency. |
7,991,930,559 |
Jul-23 |
Identiko Integrated Solution Limited |
This single award of approximately N8 billion is to a single vendor. In comparison, the entire 2023 expenditure budget for this agency, LASRRA, is about N3.2bn. This award alone is about two and a half times the entire 2023 LASRRA budget and calls for greater scrutiny. |
The Project extends across a duration of three years, necessitating funds to be allocated across multiple budget cycles rather than sourced from a single Riscal period. Notably, this initiative serves as a continuation of an ongoing contract, encompassing the augmentation of services to integrate a disaster recovery site within its scope. |
|
11. |
Special Committee on Rehabilitatio n of Public Schools |
Various |
5,813,169,527 |
Various |
Various |
These relate to various awards over the six-month period, by the Special Committee on Rehabilitation of Schools (SCRPS). Conceived as an intervention mechanism, it is not clear what the current legal framework for SCRPS is. It is listed under the Ministry of Education, but has a distinct budget and appears to operate with semi autonomous MDA-like status, awarding and overseeing substantial contracts. It is important that its activities be subjected to review, oversight and periodic audit. |
SCRPS was re-established by Mr Governor with an Executive Order on the 4th of Nov 2019. Having existed and operated by previous Administrations, it was re-introduced as a committee with the primary mandate to address the decay in the physical infrastructure in public schools. They work with the Ministry of Education for proper project identiRication and justiRication. SCRPS is subject to both State audit and external audit and other internal monitoring Agencies. They follow the State PPA laws on contract award up to project close out. All payments are executed from the State Treasury OfRice, after due certiRication by other monitoring State Agencies. |
|
12. |
Lagos State Infrastructur e Asset Management Agency |
Various |
4,289,471,036 |
Various |
Various |
The existing model where facility management contracts are awarded and managed by LASIAMA while individual, geographically dispersed MDAs occupy and use the facilities requires careful design and diligent implementation of incentives, feedback mechanisms, risk and consequence management to ensure satisfactory, safe and efRicient operations. Both LASIAMA and the |
LASIAMA, operating within the mandate of managing Lagos State assets and infrastructure plays a pivotal role in streamlining facility management across the state. The prevailing model, wherein LASIAMA administers facility management contracts while various MDAs occupy and utilize these facilities, is a strategic approach designed to centralize and optimize resource utilization. This model facilitates a cohesive and standardized management |
|
third-party facility managers are service providers to the MDAs and must deliver or bear consequences. If it is to be retained, this operating structure should be reviewed across the board and must include an effective performance management framework for LASIAMA. |
framework, ensuring uniform standards of maintenance and efRicient resource allocation. |
||||||
|
13. |
OfRice of the Chief of Staff |
Supply and distribution of 2,000 Noiler Chicken across the local government areas and wards in the state |
18,468,000 |
May-23 |
Seed and Seedlings Agricultural Enterprises |
It is not clear why the OfRice of the Chief of Staff should be engaged in supplying and distributing Chickens across the state. |
This falls under the socio-political responsibilities of government to cater for its citizens |
|
14. |
Procurement of a brand new Lexus LX 600 Bullet Proof Sport Utility Vehicle for use in the Pool of OfRice of Chief of Staff |
440,750,000 |
Jun-23 |
Lakeside Investment Limited |
This appears excessive and is out-of tune with both the prevailing economic circumstances and mood of the people. It should be scrutinized as to the need and justiRication for such a vehicle purchase and also value for money |
This is in tandem with current economic realities. |
|
|
15. |
Replacement of the liquid fragrance in the OfRice of Mr Governor, Lagos House, Ikeja. |
7,475,000 |
Jun-23 |
ARC44 Global Enterprises |
On the face of it, and especially in the present economic circumstances, the amount of this award appears excessive in relation to the item procured. |
This covers the entire 2023 period of one year. It is also not limited to Mr Governor’s ofRice but extends to several ofRices and state houses. |
|
|
16. |
Decoration of Venue for Political Delegates Congress |
20,804,550 |
Jun-23 |
Equally Diverse Solutions |
OfRicial Government Funds should not be used for political expenses. |
This was a strategic programme aimed at fostering interaction and collaboration between elected legislators and members of the State Executive Council. Its objective was to provide a conducive environment that encouraged dialogue, exchange of ideas, and cohesive engagement among these stakeholders. |
|
|
17. |
Flying Hour Expenses on Ad-hoc |
400,000,000 |
Jul-23 |
Caverton Helicopters |
This should be scrutinized as to the need and justiRication for such |
This payment accounts for past services rendered, wherein outstanding debts owed to |
|
Charter Plane by Lagos State Government |
substantial cost at taxpayer's expense and also value-for-money. |
the contractor is being reconciled and offset by this speciRic Rigure. |
|||||
|
18. |
Flying Hour Expenses on Ad-hoc Charter Plane by Lagos State Government |
112,500,000 |
Aug-23 |
Caverton Helicopters |
This should be scrutinized as to the need and justiRication for such substantial cost at taxpayer's expense and also value-for-money. |
This payment accounts for past services rendered, wherein outstanding debts owed to the contractor is being reconciled and offset by this speciRic Rigure. |
|
|
19. |
Procurement of TEN (10) UNITS brand new Hyundai County Buses for use in the Pool of the OfRice of the Chief of Staff |
600,000,006 |
Aug-23 |
VON Automobile Nigeria Limited |
it is not evident why there is a need to purchase 30 brand new buses at a total cost of N2.2 billion for use in the pool of the OfRice of the Chief of Staff |
The Chief of Staff holds oversight responsibilities across multiple MDAs within the State. However, it's important to note that these buses are designated for the use of other MDAs within the State and are not allocated for the personal use of the Chief of Staff. |
|
|
20. |
Procurement of TWENTY (20) UNITS brand new Ashok Leyland Falcon Buses for use in the Pool of the OfRice of the Chief of Staff |
1,599,999,986 |
Aug-23 |
VON Automobile Nigeria Limited |
Ditto |
The Chief of Staff holds oversight responsibilities across multiple MDAs within the State. However, it's important to note that these buses are designated for the use of other MDAs within the State and are not allocated for the personal use of the Chief of Staff. |
|
|
21. |
OfRice of the Deputy Governor |
Monthly outreach of indigent citizens by wife of the Deputy Governor |
30,000,000 |
Jul-23 |
Rodies Logistics |
Though the intention may be laudable, these should not be funded from the budget of the OfRice of the Deputy Governor |
This amount represents an annual sum, with a monthly expenditure of N2.5 million. |
|
22. |
Monthly empowerment programmes of the wife of the deputy governor |
30,000,000 |
Jul-23 |
Rodies Logistics |
Ditto |
This amount represents an annual sum, with a monthly expenditure of N2.5 million. |
|
|
23. |
Provision of Supply items (Rechargeable fans, rechargeable lights and fridge in |
2,017,840.00 |
Jul-23 |
Judkom Enterprises |
This award, which is listed here as published by the PPA, very obviously deserves further scrutiny. |
This is not the case. The contract is for N2,017,840.00 and this is what is contained on the Agency’s website and the registered Letter of Award. |
|
the ofRice of the deputy governor. |
|||||||
|
24. |
Ministry of Finance |
Collation of Revenue Data and the Review of the current Lagos State Revenue Allocation Indices in Line with Revenue Mobilization Allocation and Fiscal Commission Call Circular |
778,000,000 |
May-23 |
DYA Lorte Limited |
Maintenance and reporting of State revenue and expenditure data is a fundamental, long-standing and core responsibility of the Ministries of Finance and Economic Planning and Budget. Why there is a need for additional expenditure of this magnitude to meet reporting requirements is not clear. It requires further justiRication as it may be indicative of other capacity gaps that may need to be addressed. |
The core objective of this project is to conduct a comprehensive reassessment of Lagos State, aligning it with the standards set forth by the Revenue Mobilization Allocation and Fiscal Commission. This initiative necessitates extensive data collection conducted by local government ofRicials at their respective levels. As a result of the time constraints faced by LASG, a consultant was engaged. The project entails training, meticulous data analysis, and oversight by the commission to evaluate the ongoing efforts. |
|
25. |
Ministry of Agriculture |
Commission and Operation Start-Off support of Lagos Rice Mill Imota. |
300,000,000 |
May-23 |
Messrs WACOT Agro Ventures Limited |
LASG announced in October 2022 that it signed an agreement for WACOT to manage the Imota Rice Mill which was built at substantial cost to the taxpayer. The terms of this arrangement have not been disclosed, but LASG continues to also directly bear costs associated with running the Mill. It should be clear and unambiguous who bears what responsibilities and there should be monitoring and reporting to ensure accountability, operating efRiciency and Rinancial sustainability. Further, if the terms of the agreement bring it within the ambit of the PPP law, then the arrangement should be disclosed, regulated, monitored and reported on by the OfRice of PPP |
The collaboration with WACOT is not a Public Private Partnership (PPP) but a technical service arrangement intended to bolster the Imota Rice Mill. This partnership involves the provision of expertise from both expatriate and local staff, leveraging their experience in similar machinery and processes from Argungu, Kebbi State. It's crucial to note that the mill remains the property of LASG; the collaboration primarily focuses on training. WACOT has deployed 7 expatriates and 16 support staff to facilitate the initial operations and eventual self-sufRiciency of the mill. The initial allocation of 300 million Naira was intended for disbursement at 50 million Naira monthly over a six-month period. However, due to an expanded scope, this Rigure has been revised to 540 million Naira, allowing for a monthly disbursement of 60 million Naira for further 9 months totalling 15 months. |
|
26. |
Renewal/Extension of Technical Support Services for the |
540,000,000 |
Jul-23 |
Messrs WACOT Agro Ventures Limited |
Ditto |
The collaboration with WACOT is not a Public Private Partnership (PPP) but a technical service arrangement intended to bolster the Imota Rice Mill. This partnership involves the |
|
Management of Operations of Lagos Rice Mill Imota |
provision of expertise from both expatriate and local staff, leveraging their experience in similar machinery and processes from Argungu, Kebbi State. It's crucial to note that the mill remains the property of LASG; the collaboration primarily focuses on training. WACOT has deployed 7 expatriates and 16 support staff to facilitate the initial operations and eventual self-sufRiciency of the mill. The initial allocation of 300 million Naira was intended for disbursement at 50 million Naira monthly over a six-month period. However, due to an expanded scope, this Rigure has been revised to 540 million Naira, allowing for a monthly disbursement of 60 million Naira for further 9 months totalling 15 months. |
||||||
|
27. |
Procurement of Consumables like Threads, Charcoal, Wood, Sand, Personal protective equipment, hiring of trucks and servicing of generator plants for the second quarter operation of Lagos Rice Mill Imota. |
24,721,650 |
Jun-23 |
Lamin Global Ventures Limited |
Ditto |
The contractor's proven expertise in supplying these consumables led to the establishment of a framework agreement, enabling the consistent provision of these items over an extended period. |
|
|
28. |
Fire Service |
Procure Fuel for the State Fire and Rescue Service's Operational Activities |
850,755,000 |
Jun-23 |
Deoban 3 Plus Ltd |
Procurement of Fuel by the State should be rationalized. The State should negotiate directly for bulk product purchases from the major petroleum product marketing companies. It may then use smaller contractors for the related logistical services, fulRillment and for limited supplementary product purchases, if and when required. LASG should also |
Procuring fuel for Fire Service in this manner aligns with the state's public procurement goals which includes encouraging SME involvement. Involving smaller contractors supports SME participation and ensures operational Rlexibility. The contract is payable monthly at N70million and covers 20 Rire stations. |
|
maintain appropriate levels of strategic reserve |
|||||||
|
29. |
Lagos State Lotteries and Gaming Authority |
Implementation of Feasibility Study for Lekki-Epe International Airport |
195,000,000 |
Apr-23 |
Amion Projects Limited |
Substantial costs are being incurred by the Lagos State Lotteries and Gaming Authority far above the revenues it is generating for wide ranging and disparate purposes. As at September, the Authority’s 2023 revenues were reported at approximately N3.3bn and expenditure at approximately N11.4bn. This contradicts the rationale for the existence of the Authority and should be examined. |
The dwindling revenue cannot be substantiated and does not reRlect the true position at Lotteries Board. The enabling law creating the Board empowers it to allocate funds for expenditure relating to certain objectives including educational, infrastructural, health care and environmental objectives. |
|
30. |
Restoration of Water Supply at Iduganran Palace |
152,116,326 |
Sep-23 |
PEEC Transational Limited |
Ditto |
The dwindling revenue cannot be substantiated and does not reRlect the true position at Lotteries Board. The enabling law creating the Board empowers it to allocate funds for expenditure relating to certain objectives including educational, infrastructural, health care and environmental objectives. |
|
|
31. |
Proposed Adesalu Health Care Center at Onasa Community Ibeju Lekki |
159,314,907 |
Sep-23 |
PEEC Transational Limited |
Ditto |
The dwindling revenue cannot be substantiated and does not reRlect the true position at Lotteries Board. The enabling law creating the Board empowers it to allocate funds for expenditure relating to certain objectives including educational, infrastructural, health care and environmental objectives. |
|
|
32. |
Lagos State Parking Authority |
Procurement of 40 Nos of Vehicle Tyre Clamps Ist Batch for the Agency |
9,589,000 |
Jun-23 |
Baldwin Investment Limited |
Some of the reported actions of this agency are suggestive of an agency that is under pressure to generate revenues, whose revenue model is not fully thought through and whose enforcement tactics may be predatory. This could be further fuelled by the fact that it is operating at a substantial deRicit. For the year to September |
The Rigures provided lack substantiation and the source is unreliable. Without veriRied Rinancial data, making assumptions about the agency's revenue generation, operational model, or enforcement strategies leads to Rlawed conclusions |
|
2023, it had revenues of N450million and had incurred costs of N2.4 billion. |
|||||||
|
33. |
Engagement of the consultancy on operations management monitoring and customer tools for Lagos State parking authority |
405,456,363 |
Jul-23 |
Automata Technologies System Limited |
Ditto |
The Rigures provided lack substantiation and the source is unreliable. Without veriRied Rinancial data, making assumptions about the agency's revenue generation, operational model, or enforcement strategies leads to Rlawed conclusions |
|
|
34. |
Lagos State Electricity Board |
Supply of Transformers and Electricity Accessories |
36,367,366 |
Jun-23 |
Omron Nigeria Limited |
As at September, the Lagos State Electricity Board had a large deRicit with revenues reported for 2023 of N34 million and expenditure for the same period of N19 billion of which N5.8bn was for capital expenditure and N13.3bn for overheads. It acquires, operates and maintains generation and distribution assets to power mostly public and underserved facilities. Government has historically been shown to be inefRicient in the management of such operations and where possible, transition to efRicient private operators on commercial, competitive terms should be pursued. Where there are compelling reasons for Government to continue to operate these services, the related activities, costs, efRiciency metrics and results of operations must be tracked, benchmarked and transparently reported. |
The Lagos State Electricity Board functions as a pivotal agency overseeing various aspects of electricity provision and regulation within the state. Its primary responsibilities encompass power distribution oversight, infrastructure development, policy formulation, and implementation related to electricity generation, transmission, and distribution. Additionally, the board addresses consumer services, handling complaints, ensuring affordable access to reliable electricity, and conducting consumer education programs. It plays a regulatory role in tariffs, licensing, and quality standards for electricity services while promoting the integration of renewable energy sources into the state's electricity supply. The importance of LSEB can therefore not be over emphasized. In addition, the overhead of LSEB is expended on streetlights, diesel, payment for IPPs etc. |
|
35. |
Rehabilitation and reconnection of IPP high voltage distribution |
599,980,515 |
Sep-23 |
Mainland Power Limited |
Ditto |
The Lagos State Electricity Board functions as a pivotal agency overseeing various aspects of electricity provision and regulation within the state. Its primary responsibilities encompass |
|
network from ile zik to oshodi |
power distribution oversight, infrastructure development, policy formulation, and implementation related to electricity generation, transmission, and distribution. Additionally, the board addresses consumer services, handling complaints, ensuring affordable access to reliable electricity, and conducting consumer education programs. It plays a regulatory role in tariffs, licensing, and quality standards for electricity services while promoting the integration of renewable energy sources into the state's electricity supply. The importance of LSEB can therefore not be over emphasized. In addition, the overhead of LSEB is expended on streetlights, diesel, payment for IPPs etc. |
||||||
|
36. |
Ministry of Home Affairs |
Renovation of Saint Andrews Anglican Church, Oke-Popo, Lagos |
531,553,559 |
Aug-23 |
VicJone Nigeria Limited |
Why is LASG spending N531 million of taxpayer money to renovate a Church? |
The Church was founded in 1889 and stands as a signiRicant historical landmark in Lagos State. The need for the State to preserve such landmark can therefore not be overemphasized. The contract amount encompasses funds allocated for both the refurbishment of the Church and compensation given to the church for the necessary demolition of sections of its property due to road expansion. |
|
37. |
Center for Rural Development |
Construction of Erelu Way / Dayo Eluk Community Link Road, in Amikanle Community the Agbado-Oke Odo LCDA |
511,539,758 |
Sep-23 |
People's Choice Properties Ltd |
The Center for Rural Development was conceived to focus on research, programmatic and policy interventions to help catalyze rural development across the state. CERUD's entire budget for 2023 is N1.3 billion. By comparison, this single award is for N551 million. CERUD should not be directly engaged in the building of roads. |
CERUD's mandate encompasses providing essential amenities to rural areas, and the project spans across multiple budget cycles. |
|
38. |
Lagos State Public Procurement |
On-boarding of four MDAs and Twenty nine Hospitals unto |
379,500,000 |
Jul-23 |
Kehinde Kassim & Co. |
There should be an additional oversight and control mechanism for signiRicant procurement awards of the |
the Lagos State Public Procurement Agency operates under a governance framework that ensures rigorous oversight and control |
|
Agency |
the E-procurement system of Lagos State Public Procurement Agency |
Public Procurement Agency, as the procurement police should not be left alone to police itself. |
mechanisms beyond its internal procurement policies. The agency's activities are subject to meticulous scrutiny and audit processes conducted by both the Lagos State House of Assembly and the OfRice of the Auditor General. |
||||
|
39. |
Ministry of Economic Planning and Budget |
Consultancy Services for the engagement of monitoring and evaluation specialist for NG-CARES Implementation in Lagos State |
315,600,000 |
Jul-23 |
Duke Advisory Service |
The wisdom in spending a sum as signiRicant as this in 2023 for monitoring and evaluation of a COVID 19 recovery programme is suspect especially in light of the prevailing economic hardship. M&E should have been part of the original implementation of NG-CARES. This award should be scrutinized for value for money and/or better alternative uses at the present time. |
This is a world bank project under the Program for-Results (PforR) Rinancing instrument. Its unique features include linking disbursement of funds to the achievement of speciRic program results and supporting clients in enhancing the effectiveness and efRiciency of their development programs to achieve tangible and sustainable results. The project is currently ongoing in all 36 States of the federation. |
|
40. |
Ministry of Physical Planning and Urban Development |
Public Relations and Whistleblower strategy for the ministry of physical planning and urban development |
269,000,000 |
Jul-23 |
6334 Business Services |
This should be reviewed and assessed to ensure Value-for-money. |
The project involved a comprehensive nine month enumeration and sensitization campaign conducted by the consultant throughout Lagos State. This initiative also involved the engagement of diverse stakeholders within the informal sector, with a primary focus on augmenting data collection, fostering community awareness, and promoting regulatory compliance. |
|
41. |
OfRice of Internal Audit |
Transformation Agenda for Of Rice of Internal Audit |
100,000,000 |
Jul-23 |
Marina Consulting Limited |
This is quite vague. It should be reviewed and assessed to provide assurance of Value-for-money |
This was an extensive capacity building programme for all Auditors statewide and a process re-engineering drive. |
|
42. |
Capacity building and Competency Framework for Of Rice of Internal Audit |
100,000,000 |
Jun-23 |
Dayclar Global Ventures |
This contract, for capacity building and a competency framework for the OfRice of Internal Audit, is recorded by the PPA as being awarded to Dayclar Global Ventures, which deRines itself as a real estate company. |
The consultant, with a wealth of experience in works projects, was enlisted to conduct statewide training for auditors. The focus was on imparting prepayment inspection protocol expertise alongside comprehensive project management skills. |
|
43. |
OfRice of the Head of Service |
Procurement of 5 (Five) Brand New 2023 Mikano Changan Dynamic Saloon Vehicles for 5 lucky winners in the senior category during the recently concluded Y2023 Public Service Week. |
83,796,250 |
Aug-23 |
Mikano International Limited |
It is ill-advised to do a rafRle draw where 5 new vehicles are given out free with public funds. One vehicle would sufRice for this purpose. LASG should instead focus on ensuring public servants are well compensated and then held accountable for efRicient service delivery |
The distribution of 5 vehicles during the Public Service Week aimed to recognize senior civil servants' dedication and boost morale. The goal of this gesture, is to foster productivity among public servants. |
|
44. |
Lagos State Emergency Management Agency |
Procurement of Fuel for Lagos State Emergency Management Agency Operational Activities for the Month of April |
74,524,650 |
Apr-23 |
Messrs Aderinola Oyindamola Aboyade-Cole & Co. |
Procurement of Fuel by the State should be rationalized. The State should negotiate directly for bulk product purchases from the major petroleum product marketing companies. It may then use smaller contractors for the related logistical services, fulRillment and for limited supplementary product purchases, if and when required. LASG should also maintain appropriate levels of strategic reserve. |
Procuring fuel for LASEMA in this manner aligns with the state's public procurement goals which includes encouraging SME involvement. Involving smaller contractors supports SME participation and ensures operational Rlexibility. |
|
45. |
Ibile Oil and Gas Corporation |
Renovation of IOGC's Retail Fuel Station Located at Km 44 Lekki-Epe Expressway Ikota Lekki, Lagos |
68,000,000 |
Jul-23 |
Elsatech Nigeria Limited |
IOGC continues to operate with a substantial budget deRicit though its detailed Rinancial results are not published. It is unlikely to be efRicient and competitive in retail fuel distribution and LASG is in effect engaging in competition with businesses, including small businesses, that it should instead be supporting. The State should focus on doing what a government should do. The IOGC station at Ikota is not a busy station and has changed hands a couple of times in the last 5 years with IOGC being the latest acquirer. Yet, not |
The renovation of IOGC's retail fuel station aligns with LASG's role as a major shareholder in the organization. It's a contribution towards improving infrastructure within the state, not a competition with private businesses. LASG is committed to enhancing services for the public and addressing separate challenges like road works and trafRic through other initiatives. |
|
far down the road from the same IOGC Station are dilapidated and abandoned road works causing severe trafRic daily on this critical and rapidly growing axis |
President Bola Tinubu has rejected the dumping of obsolete equipment in Africa.
He insisted that Nigeria and other African countries desire genuine investments to foster their development and prosperity.
The President stated this at the G20 conference in Berlin, Germany.
He reaffirmed Africa’s readiness to engage in mutually beneficial business partnerships with Europe and the rest of the world.
Naija News reports that the investors’ conference is being held under the G20’s Compact with Africa initiative.
Responding to a question on whether Africa was actively encouraging trade among its nations, President Tinubu affirmed, “I’d say yes because the promotional efforts of the Chancellor, Olaf Scholz, who visited Africa recently, is equally an indication that Europe is serious about doing business with Africa.”
The President highlighted the strides made in governance and stability, particularly in Nigeria, saying the nation has continued to fine-tune its business environment and the rule of law to attract serious investors.
Addressing concerns about the importation of near-obsolete equipment to Africa, President Tinubu stated, “Yes, on Siemens, I agree that near-obsolete equipment is not the answer to what we need in Africa. The critical part to success is to be able to leapfrog from where we are today to the next generation of development, and we are opening the door for all of that.”
[NaijaNews]
President Bola Tinubu has arrived in Berlin, Germany where he is scheduled to attend the G20 Compact with Africa (CWA) Conference.
The President, who left Nigeria some minutes past 7pm on Saturday, was received on arrival by a delegation made up of the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Amb. Yusuf Tuggar, the Nigerian Head of Mission in Berlin, Amb. Regina Ocheni, and other dignitaries.
The G20 CWA conference will be taking place alongside the fourth G20 investment summit, co-hosted by the German Government and German business associations.
President Tinubu will be joining other heads of state and government of CWA member countries, bilateral partners, as well as heads of international organisations to deliberate on the immediate enhancement of economic and business cooperation with a view to outlining concrete measures to boost investments in critical areas such as energy, trade, infrastructure, and new technologies, among others.
[NaijaTimes]
The Niger State House of Assembly is set to enact a law that will provide six months maternity leave for nursing mothers in the state.
The Deputy Speaker, Afiniki Dauda, stated this on Sunday during a training session on etiquette, protocol, security, and empowerment for female political office holders in Minna, the state capital.
She said the bill was important to allow women to get the required rest after childbirth and to enhance the health of the nursing mother and her child.
The all-women event organised by the wife of the governor of Niger State, Fatima Bago, was aimed at enhancing women’s participation in governance and equipping them with the required business and life skills for them to fit into their new roles as political officeholders and wives of elected and appointed political officials.
The training was a follow-up to an earlier one organised by the First Lady, Oluremi Tinubu, in Abuja.
Dauda, in her remarks, said the six-month maternity leave would enable working-class nursing mothers to fully regain their energy and bond sufficiently with their children during the period.
Also speaking, Mrs Bago asked the women to leave a modest lifestyle devoid of extravagant character.
Resource persons at the event dwelt on several issues around gender-based violence, etiquette, security, and general conduct of women that would protect their integrity and safety as well as those of their spouses.
[Channels Tv]
The African Development Bank (AfDB) has said that high capital spending in Lagos does not always benefit the city’s poorest people.
This was contained in a report by the bank titled, ‘From Millions to Billions: Financing the Development of African Cities,’ which was obtained by Nairametrics.
According to the report, Lagos state has an approved budget of $2.1 billion for 2023/24, with $1.3 billion (58% of the entire budget) targeted at capital projects.
It, however, lamented that Lagos’s budget does not always lead to basic infrastructure and services for the poorest in the city.
The report read:
- “The relatively high capital component of Lagos State’s budget (58%) does not always translate into implementation of basic infrastructure and services for the city’s poorest people, but Lagos is deliberate in trying to attract multinational companies and foreign investment.”
On the budget breakdown and the source of revenue for the state, the report added:
- “Lagos State’s approved budget for 2023/24 (the ‘Budget of Continuity’) totalled $2.31 billion or $144 per capita, of which $1.33 billion (58%) is for capital projects and 27% specifically for new infrastructure. The balance (42%) is spent on personnel and debt servicing. This equates to a $48.22 capital budget per capita.
- “Own-source revenue in 2023/24 was estimated at $1.83 billion, with the 25-30% shortfall filled by borrowing (20%) and transfers from the federal government (10%). An estimated five million people (31% of the population) pay some form of tax or revenue to Lagos State, but only 400,000 entities are registered for PAYE. Non-compliance with tax obligations is a critical issue. Efforts are underway to change this, and an 18% growth in local revenue was recorded in 2022.
- “Currently, Lagos generates 70% of its revenue from its sources, most of which comes from PAYE (45% of revenue) and property taxes. Other sources of revenue are more volatile and include sales proceeds, rents, land-use charges, fees, and fines.”
Lagos’ PPP for the rich more than the poor
The report also noted that development in the state has been driven through public-private partnerships (PPP) with federal government tax breaks for private-sector property developers.
However, such partnerships were described as “less effective in ensuring universal access to basic services; 65% of Lagosians do not have access to electricity and 85% rely on informal sanitation.”
It also added that infrastructure spending is targeted more at those in the upper class, resulting in zero impacts on economic multiples and poverty reduction.
The report noted:
- “Lagos State has been deliberate in seeking private sector partners for capital investment with the federal government offering tax incentives (20% of the cost of providing basic infrastructure is tax deductible) to private sector investors financing road, water, and electricity infrastructure.
- “Infrastructure planning has been criticized as top-down and unable to generate the economic multipliers and poverty alleviation impacts that might be hoped for from infrastructure investments.”
On Lagos’s debt
The AfDB in its report stated that by the end of 2022, Lagos State owed $1.7 billion, and with the currency depreciating in 2023, the expense of servicing this debt was only going to increase. The state’s standing with domestic bond markets, which accounted for 20% of its debt in 2022, remained unchanged.
Although ‘balanced budgets’ are not mandated at the federal level, states must keep their deficits below 3% of GDP. Since 2016, the state of Lagos has had access to a $653 million bond, note, and other securities facility (in Nigerian Naira). As of December 2022, bonds formed 20% of Lagos State’s debt.
While Lagos currently has the most domestic revenue and foreign debt of any state in the country, it also has the highest internal revenue.
The state owes N812.4 billion to domestic creditors and another $1.3 billion to foreign creditors, according to figure provided by the Debt Management Office (DMO).
More Insight
Some major expenditures in the Lagos State Government (LASG) 2023 budget were recently made public thanks to the efforts of Funso Doherty, a professional accountant and politician residing in Lagos.
It has been disclosed by the Action Democratic Congress (ADC) gubernatorial candidate Doherty that the budget allocates massive sums of money on things like charter planes, SUVs, diffusers, and significant infrastructure.
In an open letter to Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu, Doherty listed certain allocations that, in his opinion, merit closer examination, including calling attention to a register of public procurement awards by LASG for the second and third quarters of 2023.
The replacement of liquid fragrance at the Governor’s office cost N7,475,000, while the purchase of brand-new Lexus LX 600 bulletproof sport utility vehicles cost the Chief of Staff’s office N440 million. Not only that, but the state government set aside a hefty sum of money (about N400,000,000) to cover any unexpected charter jet costs.
Doherty also voiced doubts about the N69.9 billion budgeted to rebuild and enhance a stretch of the Eti Osa/Lekki Motorway, calling the sum an excessive expenditure for road maintenance. He expressed his displeasure with wasteful expenditures and investments in infrastructure and called for greater openness and responsibility from those in charge of the country’s coffers.
The news caused a major reaction on Twitter, Facebook, and other social media sites, with many Nigerians expressing their dismay and fury at what they see as wasteful spending on the part of the Lagos State Government.
Labour Party candidate for governor of Lagos state Gbadebo Rhodes-Vivour voiced his dismay at the “irresponsible squandering of our commonwealth in such difficult times.” He criticized the misalignment between government goals and the pressing needs of the people, stating that these funds could have been used to create jobs and provide a social safety net for Lagosians.
[Nairametrics]
Benue: ‘No one will go away with APC’s mandate again’ – Akume speaks on alleged rift with Gov Alia
AdminThe Secretary to the Government of the Federation ,SGF ,and leader of the All Progressives Congress, APC, in Benue State, Sen .George Akume, has warned that the party will no longer condone any form of indiscipline from members.
Akume issued the warning over the weekend during the second stakeholders meeting of the APC at the New Banquet Hall of Government House, Makurdi.
He spoke against the backdrop of the defection of the immediate past governor, Samuel Ortom, who was elected on the platform of the party but switched to the Peoples Democratic Party, PDP , after some irreconcilable differences with APC leaders in the state.
Akume, who was represented by an elder of the APC, Çhief Simon Shango, dispelled the rumors of reported rift between him and Governor Hyacinth Alia.
Sango said insinuations of a rift between the SGF and the governor only exist in the imagination of mischief makers as the duo enjoy very cordial working and partisan relationship.
He said Akume is totally in support of Alia ‘s administration and there was no basis for acrimony between them.
Sango noted that he understands the situation in which Alia found himself because he is coming from a non-political background.
“In the Church all you need to say is an Amen but he wants the Governor to appreciate our situation and that as politicians, we may be anxious and may not wait for Amen but will start agitation and argument.
“This is to say that no one will go away with our mandate again but we will be meeting at the center,” he said.
He emphasized that the situation whereby Benue State was an orphan at the federal level for eight years should not occur again as the APC is in control at both levels again.
[DailyPost]
Since the completion of the 2023 general elections, attention has shifted to the courts that are deciding the petitions arising from the elections. In this piece, Okiki Adeduyite looks at the state governors so far sacked by courts and why they were sacked.
In a judgment on Sunday, the Court of Appeal, led by Justice Elphreda Williams-Dawodu, ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission to withdraw the Certificate of Return given to Governor Caleb Mutfwang of Plateau State.
The court declared Nentawe Goshwe of the All Progressives Congress the rightful winner of the March 18 governorship election, ordering INEC to issue a new Certificate of Return to him.
Courts have sacked at least three governors whose elections were contested by opposing parties and deemed one election inconclusive, barely nine months after the elections.
- Abba Kabir Yusuf (NNPP)
The NNPP received 1,019,602 votes to defeat the APC, whose candidate, Nasir Gawuna, received 890,705 votes, according to INEC. As a result, the NNPP candidate won by a margin of 128,897 votes.
The Election Petitions Tribunal, under the leadership of Justice Oluyemi Osadebay, invalidated the election of Governor Yusuf. The tribunal made this decision by declaring 165,663 votes, garnered by Yusuf invalid.
The ballot papers for the 165,663 votes were not signed or stamped, according to the judge, and thus were invalid.
The court ordered that Yusuf’s certificate of return be revoked and that a fresh one be issued to Gawuna.
The Court of Appeal in Abuja also upheld the tribunal’s decision.
The three-member panel, led by Justice M.A Adumeh, determined that Yusuf was not on his political party’s membership list.
He stated that a party must hold the names of its registered members in both hard and soft copies, citing a clause of the Electoral Act.
The judge stated that the tribunal erred in failing to disqualify Yusuf in its ruling.
“The tribunal was wrong not to have disqualified him. The failure to comply with Section 177(c) is fatal to their election. . Where a party carelessly nominates a candidate such is a nullity irrespective of whether he performs well. Sponsorship without membership is like putting nothing on something, it cannot stand. This is a clear example of acting with brazen impunity as if the Constitution is not binding,” he held.
Yusuf has, however, vowed to reclaim his mandate at the Supreme Court.
- Abdullahi Sule (APC)
The Nasarawa State Governorship Election Petitions Tribunal sacked the state governor, Abdullahi Sule, in October and ordered INEC to revoke his Certificate of Return and give it to David Ombugadu of the PDP.
Ombugadu had taken Sule to court to contest INEC’s announcement of Sule as the winner of the election.
He told the tribunal that his actual votes were unfairly lowered while Sule of the APC’s votes were boosted to help him win, notably in the EC8Bs of Gayam and Chiroma Wards of Lafia Local Government Area.
The tribunal, led by Justice Ezekiel Ajayi, in its decision deducted the incorrect votes added to Sule and added back the votes which were reduced from the overall votes of David Ombugadu. This decision was based on the certified copies of the polling units results (forms EC8A) that were presented by the petitioners.
The Court of Appeal sitting in Abuja on Wednesday, November 15, reserved judgment on the appeal.
- Dauda Lawal (PDP)
INEC had declared Dauda Lawal of the PDP as the winner of the Zamfara State governorship election, defeating the incumbent governor, Bello Matawalle of the APC.
Matawalle had filed a case with the tribunal contesting the results of the governorship election on March 18, but it was dismissed due to lack of merit.
The Court of Appeal issued its decision on Thursday, November 16, declaring the election inconclusive and ordering INEC to hold new elections in two local governments.
According to the appellate court, Matawalle, who is currently the Minister of State for Defence, was able to establish Lawal’s invalid election.
The governor, in a statement by his spokesperson, Sulaiman Idris, said his legal team was reviewing the judgment before taking the next necessary action.
- Caleb Mutfwang (PDP)
Nentawe Goshwe of the APC challenged the victory of Caleb Mutfwang at the tribunal, claiming that the governor was not validly nominated and sponsored by his party.
A three-member panel of the tribunal headed by Justice R. Irele-Ifijeh, in a unanimous decision, dismissed the petition of Goshwe for lacking merit.
The three-member panel of the Court of Appeal led by Justice Elfrieda Williams-Dawodu ruled on Sunday, November 19, that the governor was not legitimately sponsored by the PDP for the election, citing Section 177 of the Constitution.
The judge pointed out that the PDP failed to adhere to a standing High Court order, which mandated the party to organise a legitimate party congress before endorsing candidates for the governorship and other positions.
Mutfwang, who has directed his legal team to submit an appeal with the Supreme Court, expressed hope that the mandate bestowed upon him by the people of the state would be reinstated.
[Punch]
More...
Massive protests broke out in Jos, the capital of Plateau State, on Sunday, in response to the triumph of the All Progressives Congress (APC) gubernatorial candidate, Dr. Nentawe Yilwatda, over Governor Caleb Mutfwang of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) at the Court of Appeal in Abuja.
Naija News reported that the Appellant Court had, in a unanimous judgement, nullified the election of Governor Mutfwang over the PDP’s lack of structure and non-obedience of a Court order at the time of his nomination for the March 18 governorship election in the State.
Before Sunday’s verdict, security measures were heightened across key locations in the state capital, with stern-looking security personnel stationed at major street junctions.
However, following the announcement of the judgement, a sense of tension gripped the State, with people gathering in groups to discuss the unfolding developments.
In Jos South Local Government Area (LGA), supporters of the PDP assembled in large numbers at Gyel Roundabout to express their discontent with the verdict.
A similar protest unfolded at Angwan Rukuba junction in Jos North and Riyom LGAs within the state capital.
During the protests, a youth leader from Mangu LGA, Hon. Pankyes Yamsat, conveyed their decision to demonstrate against the Appeal Court’s judgement, which resulted in the removal of Governor Mutfwang.
He explained that the people of the State voted for Mutfwang, the people’s choice, but their mandate has been truncated at the Appeal Court.
“The mandate of the people of Plateau has been stolen, and we call on the Supreme Court to ensure justice is served with the view to reverse the judgement of the Appeal Court for peace to reign in the state,” he stated.
Meanwhile, the embattled Plateau State governor, Caleb Mutfwang, has described the verdict of the Appeal Court that nullified his election as a temporary setback that will not deter him from repositioning the State on the path of unity, peace and progress.
He expressed strong optimism that the mandate overwhelmingly given to him by the people of Plateau State would be restored, as he has instructed his legal team to file an appeal at the Supreme Court.
Mutfwang, in a statement signed by his director of press and public affairs, Gyang Bere, admonished citizens of the State and supporters of the PDP to remain calm even as he assured them that as long as God remains on the throne, the mandate of the people will be preserved and protected.
He reiterated his commitment to the rule of law and assured the people that there is light at the end of the tunnel, as he has unwavering faith in the judiciary and the constitution of Nigeria.
Governor Mutfwang concluded with a strong appeal to supporters and citizens of the State to maintain law and order. He affirmed that Plateau will be victorious to the glory of God and reassured of his commitment to continually serve the State with dedication and integrity.
On its part, the State chapter of the APC, in their reaction to the victory of Nentawe in a statement issued in Jos by the party’s state publicity secretary, Sylvanus Namang, called on all its members to celebrate the victory with utmost modesty and decorum.
According to Namang, the anger and disaffection which prevailed in the wake of the appeal should be put behind them as Plateau State was reduced to a laughing stock, which is most regrettable.
The statement called on security agencies in the State to be on red alert and vigilant to avert any breakdown of law and order while commending the Court of Appeal Judges for their meticulous, impartial and very professional handling of the appeal.
Governor Caleb Mutfwang of Plateau State has described as a temporary setback, the verdict of an Appeal Court which sacked him as governor of the state.
In a statement through his Director of Press and Public Affairs, Gyang Bere, the governor said the “temporary setback” won’t deter him from repositioning the state on the path of unity, peace and progress.
The governor admonished citizens of the state and supporters of Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) to remain calm and assured them that as God remains on the throne, his mandate will be preserved and protected.
The governor said he has instructed his legal team to file an appeal at the Supreme Court.
“He expressed strong optimism that the mandate overwhelmingly given to him by the people of Plateau State would be restored, as he has instructed his legal team to file an appeal at the Supreme Court,” the statement partly read.
Meanwhile, members of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in the state have roled our drums to celebrate the verdict of the appellate court that sacked Mutfwang.
Party faithful gathered in some areas of the Tudun Wada Ring Road of the Jos North Local Government Area of the state on Sunday to express their joy with musical instruments blasting danceable tunes.
On Sunday, an Appeal Court in Abuja sacked Mutfwang.
In her ruling on Sunday, the lead Justice, Elfrieda Williams-Dawodu, ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to issue a Certificate of Return to the candidate of the APC, Nentawe Goshwe.
Justice Williams-Dawodu set aside the judgment of the Tribunal which affirmed the election of Governor Mutfwang, describing it as highly incompetent.
According to the court, the decision of the tribunal to dismiss the petition filed by the APC and its candidate on the ground that the duo had no business meddling in the affairs of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) on which platform Mutfwang was elected is in breach of Section 177 of the 1999 Constitution as amended and Section 134 (C) of the Electoral Act.
The Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN) Justice Olukayode Ariwoola, will swear-in 58 new Senior Advocates of Nigeria (SANs) on Monday, November 27, 2023, at the main Courtroom of the Supreme Court, as part of the programmes lined up for the 2023/2024 legal year of the Court.
In line with the age-long tradition, the CJN, will, during the special court session, deliver a state-of-the Judiciary address that would highlight the performance of the Apex Court and the Nigerian Judiciary in general in the 2022/2023 legal year.
The Director of Press and Information of the Apex Court, Dr Akande Festus made this known in a press statement he issued on Sunday in Abuja.
According to him, other leading stakeholders in the Justice Sector will present speeches bordering on the state of the justice sector of the country at the occasion.
They include the Attorney General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Chairman of the Body of Senior Advocates of Nigeria (BOSAN) and the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) amongst others.
114 applications were earlier received by the Legal Practitioners’ Privileges Committee (LPPC) for the award of the rank of Senior Advocate of Nigeria in 2023.
Out of the number, 101 are advocates while 13 are academics.
The total number of qualified applicants shortlisted after the Advocates 1st and 2nd Filtration Stages, Academic Pre-qualification, Academic 2nd Filtration Exercise, the Independent Appeals Hearing and Chambers Inspection Exercises was 69 comprising 57 advocates and 12 academics.
After conducting the specified screening and filtration exercises which include a number of appearances in superior courts, recommendations by Justices of the Supreme Court and Judges of superior courts, Chamber inspections; approval on eligibility and integrity of the candidates from the Nigerian Bar Association, Body of Senior Advocates of Nigeria and the general public, amongst others, the LPPC came up with 58 successful candidates.
Out of the figure, 57 are advocates while one is an academic.
The Association of Resident Doctors, Enugu chapter has given the state government a 14-day ultimatum to employ new doctors in the health institution or risk industrial action.
In a communique issued at its Emergency General Meeting (EGM) and signed by the association’s President, Dr Chukwunonso Ofonere, the body resolved that there should be urgent approval for the recruitment of medical officers, resident doctors and house officers in the hospital especially at the Accident and Emergency Department, surgery department, internal medicine department, paediatrics department, obstetrics and gynaecology departments etc.
According to Ofonere, the resident doctors in the aforementioned department have left the institution in the past four years and were never replaced.
They are asking the hospital management to ensure the implementation of safety policies to protect their workers against physical attacks and kidnap within one week as promised by the Chief Medical Director and finally, immediate implementation of the 2023 Medical Residency Training Fund (MRTF) as their colleagues in other states.
“First, the management should declare a state of emergency on the employment of doctors in the hospital. There should be an urgent approval for the recruitment of medical officers, resident doctors and house officers in the hospital,” the statement read.
“This recruitment should be focused especially at the Accident and Emergency Department, Surgery Department, Internal Medicine Department, Paediatrics Department, Obstetrics and Gynaecology Departments.
“Secondly, management should ensure the implementation of safety policies to protect her workers against physical attacks and kidnap within one week as promised by the chief medical director (CMD).
“Thirdly, the immediate implementation of the 2023 Medical Residency Training Fund (MRTF) as our counterpart in other states; even as attached to this communique is the list of the eligible doctors and the financial implications.